Door access systems compared: card, fingerprint, face, PIN and mobile

Cards are simple to issue but can be lent, while a fingerprint or a face cannot. A PIN is a back-up, a phone suits staff who carry the app, and each door has its own answer.

Employee using a face recognition access terminal beside an office door

The five methods side by side

Here are door access systems compared by the five ways a person can identify at a door: card, fingerprint, face recognition, PIN and mobile phone. Few sites use one method for the whole building: most mix two, such as biometrics for staff and cards or QR codes for visitors and contractors.

Our page on the access control system in Dubai explains what goes on each door: reader, lock, door contact, exit button and controller. This article is about the credential, door by door.

CardFingerprintFace recognitionPINMobile (BLE or QR)
Speed at the doorQuick: hold the card to the readerSuits short queuesQuick: walk up and lookSlower: a code is keyed inPhone must be in hand
Touch-freeYesNoYesNoYes
Can be lent to someone elseYesNoNoYesOnly with the phone
VisitorsYes: a visitor cardNo: needs enrolmentNo: needs enrolmentNo: use a card or QR passYes: a QR e-pass
Running costReplacement cardsNoneNoneNoneNone

How each method behaves at the door

The table is not an order of merit: each method has a door it suits and a weakness to plan around.

Card and RFID: the default for general office doors

Cards suit general office doors, visitors and short-term staff. A card is simple to hand out, every entry appears in one log, no biometric data is collected, and a lost card can be blocked immediately across every door. Matrix readers come in versions for EM Prox, Mifare (including DESFire) and HID iCLASS cards.

The weakness is that a card can be lent, lost or forgotten, and replacement cards are a running cost. Anti-passback, where a card cannot be passed back through the door for a second person, limits one kind of sharing.

COSEC PATH devices are slim, screenless door controllers and readers, in card-only and fingerprint-and-card versions. The COSEC ARC DC200P is not a reader: it is a two-door controller with no reader of its own, which works with PATH readers or third-party RFID card readers.

Fingerprint: when sharing is the main problem

A fingerprint cannot be lent to a colleague. It suits offices with a fixed team: nothing to carry and no cards to replace. Where the same reader records attendance, the usual worry is buddy punching, one person clocking in for another, and a fingerprint is harder to cheat than a card.

The limit is hands. Fingerprint readers work poorly with dusty, wet or gloved hands, which makes them the wrong choice for warehouses, kitchens and workshops, and everyone touches the same sensor. There we fit face recognition, or a fingerprint reader that also takes a card, so nobody is locked out.

The COSEC VEGA FAX is a fingerprint and card terminal that also accepts a PIN or a phone over BLE.

Face recognition: for busy staff entrances

Face recognition suits busy staff entrances and anywhere fingerprints struggle with gloves or dust. Staff walk up, look at the screen and are identified without touching anything. Matrix's figure for the COSEC ARGO FACE is identification in under one second, and a face terminal handles a queue at shift change faster than a fingerprint reader.

Matrix also lists passive liveness detection on the FACE300 model, and up to 30 face templates per user plus adaptive templates that update over time. If staff wear masks or glasses, we recommend testing with your own staff during enrolment. Anyone not enrolled can use a card or a QR code at the same terminal.

Face is not needed on every door. A fingerprint terminal such as VEGA FAX costs less, and our rule of thumb is biometrics on high-security doors and staff entrances, cards for general office doors.

PIN: only as a back-up

A PIN works as a back-up and, on its own, only for low-risk rooms. A code can be told to anyone, so the log shows which code was used, not who keyed it in, and a keypad is not touch-free. VEGA FAX and ARGO FACE both accept a PIN as well as their main credential.

Mobile (BLE and QR): a phone as the pass

A mobile credential puts the pass on a phone. For staff this is COSEC APTA, the COSEC app for Android and iPhone, which opens doors by Bluetooth (BLE) or QR. APTA comes with the COSEC ESS licence on CENTRA or VYOM, which we include on the quote, and VEGA FAX, PATH and ARGO FACE all list BLE among their credentials.

It suits staff who carry the app, as an option beside a card or a biometric: a phone can run out of battery or be left behind.

For visitors, the pass is sent to the visitor's phone. The visitor management system issues QR e-passes that work only on the doors and turnstiles you allow and stop working at check-out, so reception has no plastic card to hand out and collect.

Which method for which door

A typical office ends up with a face or fingerprint terminal at the staff entrance, cards on general doors and a QR pass for visitors. The survey settles each door.

DoorMain methodBack-up or alternative
Main staff entrance, busy at shift changeFace recognitionCard or PIN on the same terminal
Staff entrance, office with a fixed teamFingerprintCard on the same terminal
Warehouse, workshop or kitchen entranceFace recognitionA fingerprint reader that also takes a card
General office doorsCardPhone over BLE
Meeting room or other low-risk roomCardPIN
Server room or cash officeFingerprint with cardTwo-person rule
Visitor door or receptionQR e-pass issued by the visitor management systemVisitor card

Keep the stricter combinations for doors that protect data or money. Fingerprint with card uses 1:1 fingerprint verification, which VEGA FAX and PATH both support: the card says who the person is and the finger confirms it. The two-person rule opens a server room or cash office only when two authorised people present credentials. On general office doors, a second step only slows people down.

Attendance is not the same as access

One COSEC entrance terminal can do both jobs: it opens the door and records the punch for time attendance at the same time, so staff identify once. The two jobs still ask for different things: attendance has to stop one person clocking in for another, which points to a face or a fingerprint at the staff entrance, and inner doors have to be quick to pass, which points to cards.

If you are choosing for attendance rather than doors, read our comparison of fingerprint, face recognition and card attendance.

Biometric data: what to agree before enrolment

Fingerprints and face templates are biometric data, which the UAE data protection law treats as sensitive personal data. Before anyone is enrolled, agree with your HR or legal team what staff are told at enrolment, who can see the records and where the data is stored. The data can sit on your own server with COSEC CENTRA or in the cloud with COSEC VYOM.

What to decide before the quote

Send these with your enquiry, or have them ready for the survey.

  • Doors: count them and group them: main entrance, floor doors, server room, finance, meeting rooms, visitor door.
  • Peak traffic: roughly how many people use the main entrance at the busiest time, such as a shift change.
  • Sharing: whether lent cards are a real problem, for example on shift work, or a minor one.
  • Hands: any entrance where staff wear gloves or have dusty or wet hands.
  • Cards and readers in use: the card type, and any readers you want to keep.
  • Visitors: how many on a busy day, and whether they get a QR pass on the phone or a card.
  • Attendance and data: whether the entrance terminal must also record attendance, and whether the data should sit on your own server or in the cloud.

With those, we survey each door and quote readers, locks and controllers per door, with each device listed by make and model.

Questions

Which door access system is best for a small Dubai office?

A common starting point is a fingerprint or face terminal at the staff entrance and cards on general office doors. For a few doors, terminals running directly on COSEC CENTRA or VYOM are simpler than adding a multi-door panel.

Can we keep the access cards and readers we already have?

Often. Matrix terminals are ordered in the variant that matches your card technology (EM Prox, Mifare or HID iCLASS), and existing third-party readers can usually stay if they output Wiegand or OSDP, connected to a COSEC ARC DC200P controller. We check the reader model and card format on the survey.

Can one reader do both attendance and access?

Yes. With Matrix COSEC the entrance terminal opens the door and records the attendance punch at the same time. Where there is no door to control, the ARGO FACE210T is an attendance-only version with no door connection.

What is the downside of PIN only?

A code can be passed on, so a PIN shows that someone knew the code, not who was at the door. Use it as a back-up or for low-risk rooms, and keep a card or a biometric as the main credential.

Choose an access method for each door

Tell us how many doors you have and who needs to get through them, and we will survey each door and quote readers, locks and controllers per door.

+971 55 288 6114Call or WhatsApp, Monday to Saturday, 9:00 to 18:00
info@oneexpertis.comFloor plans and tender drawings welcome (PDF or DWG)
Al Wasl Building, Bur DubaiOffice 139, F5-B, Fifth Floor, near Bur Dubai Civil Defence
Please enter your name.
Please enter a number we can call, for example +971 50 123 4567.
Please choose the type of premises.

Sends your details to us on WhatsApp. We use them only to arrange your survey.

WhatsApp us